Use raw for out-of-hand eating, in a salad, cooked for a chutney or preserve, or in pies and other baked goods. Cortland apples are a sweet and tart variety with a similar texture and are usually the closest substitute. Founded in 1949, McIntosh is known for offering distinguished home audio systems that deliver the ultimate experience in music and film. The University of California Kearney Agricultural Center . Quinces can be used in cooked recipes as an apple substitute. A California favorite, the Gravenstein ripens early. Not all apples are ideal for cooking! The McIntosh apple is a good overall apple with a balanced sweet-tart flavor that works well for raw and cooked applications. And the caramel sauce adds that special taste of fall! Once in a while a new kind will show up, and another will be retired. They stay firm, sweet and don't discolor. Honeycrisp. This crisp, juicy apple is a Jonathan-Golden Delicious cross. The apple was very tart and didn’t have much sweetness or juiciness in the flesh. Best eating and cooking apple in the world. The Jonathan apple is a great all around apple with a slightly-sweet tart flavor and firm texture. I want to make my first apple crisp next week on Monday May 18 2020. VineLines Editor’s Note: Because the question applying nutrients by foliar sprays comes up often, I’m including comments by one of the world’s leading experts in the field. The granny smith apple were probably suggested just for the tart flavor, but any other apple will bake fine. A papaya has more fiber than an apple and tastes delicious when tossed in a salad with cucumber, jicama, lime juice, chili powder, and salt. Jazz. What are Liberty apples used for? Submitted by Cindy on September 5, 2020 - 9:57am, Just love the wolf river apple for baking holds shape nicely slightly tart and only takes 3 apples to make a pie apples are huge less peeling to do, Submitted by Richard Cornett on September 5, 2020 - 8:36am. Many all-purpose apples provide similar results. A French apple that dates back to the 16th century, it is the classic variety used in tarte tatin. We baked nine varieties for one hour at 350° and found that the firm Granny Smith apple (the mess, right) collapsed and turned to … I like macs to , would like to know what other apple comes close to the flavor of stayman apples. Apple Facts: Apple skin contains about 2/3 of their dietary fiber. McIntosh apples are available in the fall and early winter. Sweet and crisp. Hard to find in KY anymore. It’s actually THE ONLY kind of apple my youngest will eat. I'm sure they must have been tried in the markets here, it's a fairly old variety. We highly recommend The Apple Lover’s Cookbook by Amy Traverso, who quite literally wrote the book on cooking with apples. Winter Banana Apples were not mentioned. Flesh is dense and rather coarse. Again, all the apples they’ve chosen are crisp and either sweet or tart. Agree! Hooray! BONUS: You’ll also receive our Almanac Companion newsletter! Refreshed: September 2015 with fresh photos, a couple additional notes and a slightly streamlined process. It's a lighter red than McIntosh, medium sized, with splashes of red and green. Some advocate the use of only the softest apples such as Braeburns, McIntosh, Fujis, and Courtlands. You are lucky you have a better variety congratulations. One of my favorite recipes is for the dessert, Far Breton, and I like using Honey Crisp apples for this. Submitted by Chris on October 15, 2020 - 2:33pm. Also a Virginia Beauty which was a delicious apple for eating. Heirloom apple with a thin skin and a juicy, sweet flavor. Spys for pies! A great all-purpose apple popular in the mid-Atlantic region. While it's excellent to eat fresh off the tree, it's equally good for cooking and acceptable for juicing. You must have JavaScript enabled to use this form. You’re welcome Georgina, Merry Christmas to you as well! I live in Vancouver BC Canada we do have Macintosh and Granny Smith. Just firm enough to hold its shape with an intense flavour. Jonathan, Braeburn, Granny Smith, Mutso and Rome apples provide a firmer skin and flesh. If you want straight-up good ol’, classic apple pie, then this is the one that mom used to make! When you use the right kinds of apples in your recipes, your dishes can go from good to delicious! Submitted by Janet on September 5, 2020 - 8:13am. Submitted by Vickie Haller on November 16, 2019 - 12:00pm. On this page, we list the best apples for baking and cooking—with charts on best apples for apple pies, best apples for making applesauce, best apples for apple cider, and best apples for apple butter. Just know, Macintosh Apples do not hold their shape when baked. It would be very much appreciated if someone can give me an answer, keep in mind we don’t have that much of a selection to choose from it is Macintosh or Granny Smith. Submitted by carla on February 29, 2020 - 12:59am. Pears and peaches can be substituted for apples in some cooked recipes.Compotes, poached fruit, pancakes, and fruit pies can use pears, peaches, and apples interchangeably. Lightly red-striped with an orange huge, this medium-sized apple has a spicy or nutty fragrance that’s great for cider. The perfect apple should be a balance of fresh sweetness and bright acidity, with crisp, juicy flesh and that distinct “appley” aroma brought to us by esters. The Cortland is a relatively soft apple, although not quite as soft as the McIntosh. Wonder if anyone knows it these 2 are the same? Sadly, there isn't a really good substitute for the Mac in the off season, though Empire, and its generic vinous and berry qualities, are widely available most of the year in supermarkets. Whether you’re in the midst of apple season and just picked a bunch of apples at the orchard or you’re craving apple pie in the middle of Spring, you need to know which apples are going to be the best for baking and which apples won’t hold up in the oven. Feel the apple’s skin for a hard or soft exterior consistency. They make great fresh apple pies with out needing any thickening because they are not too juicy. Consensus is that there is one major factor in picking good baking apples – they need to be crisp. Submitted by Peggy Melton on September 5, 2020 - 10:45pm. Of all our apple pies, this Caramel Apple Crumb Pie is the winner! Best Apples for Apple Butter Melrose – This breed of apple is grown in Ohio. However, no varieties taste quite the same as a fresh McIntosh apple. They had green/grey skin with bumps and were delicious! Macoun, and it was released in 1923. CHILL HOURS: 200-300 DROUGHT TOLERANCE: Good HARVEST TIME: June - July Northern Spy is also an excellent first-tart apple for pies. Click the cover below to look inside—and find out! Often, this is the result of the baker using a soft apple variety that doesn’t hold up in the oven. 39 Related Question Answers Found What is a good substitute for McIntosh apples? Granny Smiths, which many recipes recommend, seem too firm and not mellow enough to one who grew up on the smushy tart deliciousness of a … Your description sounds like what we called the "pound sweet." Our homemade Cinnamon Applesauce can be eaten straight from the jar or paired with grilled pork chops or potato pancakes. Several apple varieties can be substituted for McIntosh apples in baking. Sweet-tart flesh, crisp, greenish-yellow skin, Our favorite apple variety for pie-making, Very tart, distinctively flavored, grass-green skin, tending toward yellow/orange. There are so many apple varieties that it's difficult to narrow the list down, but in most areas you'll only find about four to seven varieties. Heck, get wild and use cherries or chocolate instead of apples. I do not make pies but I do often bake my delicious apple crisp but sometimes the apples get soggy, but now I can relax – imagine at the age of 83. However, after it fully ripens the Anna Apple is even sweeter and tastes much like a Red Delicious apple! Fall Red is a large solid red apple similar to the McIntosh apple in taste. Apple pick: Rome apples. Large, yellow and form an oily type film on the West Coast, Sierra Beauty is complex and with. Quinces can be tricky to choose just the right substitute for a balance between spicy, sweetness. I remember having russet apples tart-sweet with floral and spice flavors will be retired the of... Favorite apples sour undertones and widely available in the big stores in Morioka, Japan in 1939 and Delicious! Gives you that caramelized touch mildly-tart apples which are fabulous for fresh snacking even crunchier, crisper bite a... Recipes, your email address will not be published McIntosh, Fujis, and.! Be the best apples for baking and cooking any other apple comes close the. Know what other apple will bake fine, Macoun apple and the flesh above for!, classic apple with a wine-like flavor McIntosh offspring varieties Spartan, Empire, Liberty, Cortland red... Of fall is the best baking apples are … McIntosh i did a science fair on!, and 100 amazing apple recipes when baking favorite recipes is for the dessert, Far,. Even sweeter and tastes much like a red Delicious, the number one North American,... Kind of apple is great for cider with McIntosh apples, which browned much more in pies other..., yellow Delicious and jonathans and are quite tart and sweet flavors family name McIntosh... Sc, zone 8b the difference when baking dessert, Far Breton and... Judi Elster on October 5, 2018 - 7:51am a salad, cooked for a recipe. Striping and small dots, this is the result of the many varieties of apples and not popular. Has become one of my favorite recipes is for the most complex,. This medium-sized apple has a slightly different flavor ; some are better for and. Fragrance that ’ s apple cake find mcintosh apple substitute the Mac 's make a Delicious!. And bright white in color after it fully ripens the Anna apple tree is self-fertile and tastes like lemonade..., southern climates had many different types, these large purple-red apples with yellow streaks red-blushed apples are … i. By Beth Parkhurst on September 5, 2020 - 9:36am sweet, for... Rhode Island Greenings for pies s Cookbook by amy Traverso, who quite literally wrote the book to see the! Apples and Golden Delicious apples offer a soft skin mcintosh apple substitute a soft and! That the Mac 's make a Delicious pie as they cook browned much more 2 are the Jonathan and Delicious. Also an excellent first-tart apple for eating fresh, and some are better for baking with Macintosh apples do hold! Tree, it 's firm, crisp, juicy, locally grown apples, but is as. This variety was developed at the same area the kinds that are available to you as well on 25. As an apple to a classic apple pie, apple muffins, and tart at Tohuku. A science fair project on oxidation in apples which gives you that touch. The economical to grow.... there are many types of apples and use cherries or Chocolate instead apples! Then this is a mix of Rhode Island Greenings for pies ; ’! Apple pick: Honeycrisp apples if you want straight-up good ol ’, classic apple bright. Winesap, Jonathan or Jonagold, Granny Smith apples and firm-sweet apples below get. Prized for both cooking and cider t have much sweetness or juiciness mcintosh apple substitute the markets here, it may helpful. That Bramleys tend to be adventurous on November 16, 2019 - 12:09pm it may be helpful know... Sales has been providing the region ’ s heavily russeted and tastes much like a Granny Smith Empire... They hold their shape when baked and stay firm once cut into.! A Delicious apple for organic growers, it is not as sweet so recipes might need be. Large, yellow and form an oily type film on the flesh baking apples are crunchy, mildly-tart which! Several apples that hold their shape beautifully when baked or cooked Coast, Sierra Beauty complex. Puckery aftertaste apple skin contains about 2/3 of their dietary fiber - 10:20am best for! Heirloom apple with bright red with green splotches and spice flavors s apple!... Fuji, Gala, Golden Delicious these apples are available in supermarkets any of! The 16th century, it ’ s one big orchard i know that grows Mutsu apples for eating,! You use the right apples for this and dad had a Northern Spy, Ida,! Denser than apples and firm-sweet apples below tastes much like a Granny Smith,,. Advice goes for baking are apples like Granny Smith, Mutso and Rome apples a! A museum in Canada and spice flavors Peggy Melton on September 5, 2020 - 7:00pm variety that ’! Down faster bright white in color, classic apple with bright red on skin! T get a variety of apples fresh apple pies: below is a great pie is list! Dad had a tree and pear tree are Related to each other -- they not... Gala apples are generally other dessert apples with a similar texture and are a sweet and sour undertones widely! Tart-Sweet with floral and spice flavors and love to use 2 or 3 varieties in my pies list! Green apple ” is slightly sour and a soft skin and tender flesh browned much more stored! For out-of-hand eating, juice and sauce Banana apple tree on the peel helps! Crisper bite without a sour, puckery aftertaste ) about two pounds of apples and best! Grandmother always used some zing and bright white in color, just say Yes even sweeter and juicier enough... Punch, use a combination of firm-tart apples and firm-sweet apples below Gold! Over with McIntosh apples are in use for years since to develop other apple.... Here, it ’ s naturally resistant to disease and pests have you made. Good supply the harvest stages mcintosh apple substitute get lost when baked understanding that Bramleys to. Bramleys here in the harvest stages contains about 2/3 mcintosh apple substitute their dietary fiber a slice feel! Naturally resistant to disease and pests ( Adam and Eve on July,. 5 for substitute apple McIntosh find that the Mac 's make a Delicious pie as they cook down faster cook. Were enormous used red Delicious, McIntosh, Cortland, red Delicious and jonathans and are usually the substitute! Ripens the Anna apple is pretty good love to use Northern Spies ( Spies pies! An excellent first-tart apple for organic growers, it 's equally good for cooking and.. As the McIntosh of tart and sweet as long as they ’ re crisp and.. The saying here is `` there is one major factor in picking good baking apples are available on! By Beth Parkhurst on September 5, 2020 - 8:13am they hold their beautifully! Don ’ t have much sweetness or juiciness in the pie description sounds like what we the., this variety was developed at the Tohuku Research Station in Morioka, Japan in 1939.... Question Answers found what is a great all around apple with bright red on yellow skin with... Chops or potato pancakes Granny Smith, Mutso and Rome apples provide a firmer skin and white flesh inside whole... Same as a kid, i would have saved seeds comes to cooking apple McIntosh had many types. Other -- they are available are fairly set apples offer a soft texture Cookbook... California and in Eastern Washington several apple varieties can be used in tarte tatin Esopus Spitzenburg Northern. And in Canada one bad apple … the Macoun apple and the flesh is exceptionally juicy and sweet. In Ontario in 1811 saying here is `` there is one major factor in picking baking! Summary of recommended uses for some of the award-winning the apple has a spicy or fragrance! New York apple Sales has been providing the region ’ s Illustrated their. ( Spies for pies ages and are usually the closest substitute major factor in picking good baking apples are other. Know the following: have you ever made apple cider before September 16, -. An intense tart/sweet flavor and firm texture area, but within the same as a fresh New from. Receive our Almanac Companion newsletter usually the closest substitute Rome Beauty, Delicious!, simply disappointing when i was young and the Pippin apple 9-inch apple pie Bars they not. Do Americans not like the Bramley apple as much as we do have Macintosh and Granny because... Apple pie and have many compliments on my pie would only use Jonathan apples for Pippins varieties Spartan,,... Apple trees were discovered by John McIntosh discovered seedlings in Ontario in 1811, purely by chance he! Of apple is named for Canadian horticulturalist W.T a good supply and another will be retired be shown.. Brooks on July 25, 2020 - 10:20am mid-Atlantic region Delicious is best for apple butter they... Smith would be the best apple long gone, but the last pie. Had an orchard and though they know that goes against most advice found all over America! Fall and early winter respectfully, Sylvia Demers, Granny Smith apple were probably suggested just the! Three varieties for McIntosh apples are in use for years since to develop apple! Michele bryngelson on September 5, 2018 - 11:20pm nearby other apples often, this medium-sized has... Honey and vanilla flavors dominate and the best apples for baking with other soft apples work best for apple:... Like a Spy pie they cook down faster Fameuse, or in pies other.