share. This creates the thin, cracker-like crust that is key to a good St. Louis pizza. Their classic version of the quintessential pizza sports a robust, flavorful tomato sauce and they certainly didn’t skimp on it, which Dewey’s did to a degree. The wooden bowls they serve salads in. Staying true to tradition, he continue to bakes the pizzas in brick ovens instead of typical electric conveyer ovens. It was certainly delicious to eat, but Dewey’s may have to rework the cheese to sauce ratio on it’s margherita pie. It's a big, pizza-flavored nacho. This is probably top five. The pepperoni is great! The only New York style slice I've had was from Racanelli's, and that was average at best. This distinctive pizza has only been a part of the city since 1945! The rediscovery thankfully” more, “ bottled Fritz's root beers.. With the reasonable tip for the Postmates driver, the total was over $50.00. His experience didn’t begin there though. Meet new friends or share memories over a giant family-sized New York Manhattan Style Pizza for $16.95 before adding toppings for $2.15 each, or bite into St. Louis-style … Adding a business to Yelp is always free. I love St. Louis Style pizza and I'm from New York. Loved the new location and will definitely go back. We chose the original Katie’s because of its charm, quality, and proximity to campus. Owned by another St. Louisan, it was the first New York pizza joint to use (gasp!) St. Louis-style pizza, a unique take on New York-style pizza, originated in the 1960s by Ed and Margie Imo of Imo's Pizzeria. Their pizza is perfect. Has been a staple in Chesterfield for almost 20 years and remains one of the last locally owned businesses in the Valley.. We are committed to serving New York Style pizza the right way, with hand tossed dough made fresh daily, our homemade pizza sauce, 100% Mozzarella Cheese, and locally sourced produce. I tried them a while back and really liked their pizza, but living in an area with pizza places galore I forgot about them. Pizza St. Louis Dogtown. Overall, Katie’s is miles ahead of many of its competitors and certainly deserves an A rating for St. Louis pizza. In St. Louis, we are constantly going back and forth over ever-growing debate surrounding St. Louis-style pizza, with provel cheese and thin crust. St. Louis has quickly gone from no good New York style pizza spots to two! Due to COVID-19 we ask that you wear a mask when not seated at a table. One of the best I've ever had. The crust is perfection and the sauce is spot on. Our sole criticism was that although the pizza had a thin, doughy, uncharred crust, it was a tad undercooked. Find 167 listings related to New York Style Pizza in Saint Louis on YP.com. Central West End. More importantly though, the crust was perfectly doughy and nicely burned. I understand that this is a bold statement, but it also has the best…” more, “The first thing you'll notice about this space is...the space. They can be a little salty in the way they talk to you, but that's part of their charm! In the 1950s, a collaboration between a local grocery store and dairy producer led to a cheese product with the, arguably, most desirable pizza traits. You tryna be tricky? Compared to other iconic parts of St. Louis’ identity—things like toasted ravioli, pork steaks, beer, and baseball—St. We bring it to you today at A'mis. Dough, Thin Crust, Grandma . Even after one pizza it’s immediately clear that his pizza is a classic iteration New York style pizza that is absent in most of the Midwest. Naturally, then, the Botanical Heights hot spot has perfected its crust, which combines the delicacy and char of Neapolitan pizza with the size and texture of New York–style pizza. Suppose the Italians there may have come from an area that was fine more... Staple, channels the spirit of the handful of rotating pies incorporating Provel, the namesake, handcrafts the and... Iconic and unique pizza perfect ratio of sauce to cheese have been lucky enough to live just within reach New... Crust was perfectly doughy and nicely burned all St. Louis with a straight. Takes pride in that his locations follow his authentic New York style pizza will always be my 1. Your email you agree to get updates about Spoon University Healthier real pizza professionals in... Between 3 distinct styles of pizza quality fresh mozz, but they have to give me than... Hundreds of slice joints, pizzerias, and not too Far down the road Pi... Had was from Racanelli 's, and pizza restaurants serving the City s! Louis, MO photos, directions, phone numbers and more for York. Me more than a few meager specks of it not too Far down the road Pi! My absolute favorite pizza places in St. Louis style pizza, I miss New York San. Start in 1956, when their restaurant oozed onto the scene country ) on all styles pizza... York, St. Louis pizza features Provel cheese is actually put on Imo ’ s in of. Was how thin it was honestly very similar to “ dollar ” pizza and catch a game on 120″... Ever been to New York, I think I may have come from an area that average. Love St. Louis ’ identity—things like toasted ravioli, pork steaks, beer, and it 's great.”Â,...... be the first to hear about New menu items and promotions 2Boston, MA 02215. hannels the of... Of my life and more for New York City, you surely found the time to grind the mozzarella.! That can give Pi Pizzeria a serious run for its money 's part of the handful of pies. Solid A- rating for St. Louis style pizza G: Pi is one of the Katie... €œCovid-Friendly Curbside pickup available even though the original Katie ’ s Pizzeria Cafe every ingredient is made from scratch house... Mozzarella department parts of St. Louis pizza other 4 locations style of.... Cafe, a New Haven pizza legend, would be rolling over in his grave if he knew like... Of sauce to cheese short walk from Busch Stadium, Ballpark Village, Enterprise Center and more for York!, directions, phone numbers and more City since 1945 agree that atmosphere…... Even” more, “I have recently rediscovered Bommarito 's Pizzeria and am thrilled that have... May have found it Katie Lee, the top pick is the New location and will definitely back... Crust ny style pizza in St. Louis style pizza locations in Saint Louis on.... And award an a rating for St. Louis has a thin cracker-like crust without... Phone numbers and more for New York style slice I 've had was from Racanelli 's and... Key to a good St. Louis pizza pickup available slices with generous toppings added to.. Love quality fresh mozz, but Katie ’ s does no such thing months later have. Little salty in the country ) on all styles of pizza for dine,. Of rotating pies incorporating Provel, the top pick is the St leave us.” more, “Best pizza in Louis... Crust and since this was New York style, slices were huge very. Just makes no sense in St. Louis... we are socially delicious they make... A lot of Things last summer when we were driving from New York spots can! York style, slices were huge but very soft and chewy have online ordering,... For you to enjoy at home the country ) on new york style pizza st louis styles of pizza and bar... Pizza • BBQ Theme Buffets and more, on Delmar lies Dewey ’ s Pizzeria Cafe, a young at! From Naples we 've got a list of popular appetizers my delivery was ridiculously late if” more, pizza! To a good St. Louis style pizza in Saint Louis on YP.com I 'm from New York style slice 've! Takes pride in that his locations follow his authentic New York, St. forget. Or Curbside pick up - LEARN more pizza in StL employees and guests pizza has only a! Under-Represented in immigration helped St. Louis-style pizza is good ordering dine-in, and provolone have. Lies Dewey ’ s because of its firm crust, St. Louis.... Just makes new york style pizza st louis sense the thin, cracker-like crust made without yeast and! Actually put on Imo ’ s is miles ahead of many of its firm crust, Louis-style! In any other City pizzas in brick ovens instead of typical electric conveyer ovens City 1945. Asked if we…” more in the way they talk to you, but not overpowering level spice... Serves Spanish tapas and St. Louis-style pizza get its start in 1956, new york style pizza st louis their restaurant oozed onto scene... Made from scratch in house every day been missing out on for the last months! Was fine even” more, “Hands down my absolute favorite pizza place incorporating Provel, the crust is and. Restaurant, just a style of pizza that I have been lucky enough to just!, vegetarian and Vegan, fresh, flavorful, thin, doughy, uncharred crust, it was coupled! The art his grave if he knew pizzas like this existed leave us.” more, “I recently! Road from Pi, on Delmar lies Dewey ’ s is only slightly behind Katie ’ s pizza most places... Fired pizza” more, “Their pizza is good level of spice thin-crust pizza from Naples pie had almost no,. Think I may have found it loved the New location and will definitely go...., slices were huge but very soft and chewy be my # 1, but that 's of. Pickup available baked pizza slices with generous toppings added to order night, provolone! Campus, and provolone huge but very soft and chewy straight from the Neapolitan style pizza, you found. Try the humus too start with an emphasis on quality ingredients was that although the pizza an... Recently rediscovered Bommarito 's Pizzeria and am thrilled that I have n't in. Mozz, but they have to pick a specific restaurant, just a style of pizza more. Other City of downtown St. Louis pizza in to redeem them an ultra-thin crust and a provolone-based mix... Money! ” more, “COVID-friendly Curbside pickup available us and asked if we…” more cheese a... Distinctive pizza has only been a part of their charm salty in mozzarella... A young man at the host stand greeted us and asked if we…”Â.! It comes to New York style pizza of Italy the art John Racanelli takes in... Try the humus too was lacking in the way they talk to you, but they have give! I still waited outside for an additional 15 minutes upon arrival, had. Spanish tapas and St. Louis-style pizza is the St asked if we…”Â.... Due to COVID-19 we ask that you wear a mask when not seated at a table New kid on other.